Ariana Grande and Cynthia Erivo Dazzle in NBC's Wicked: One Wonderful Night

Darren Criss Makes Broadway Comeback in Maybe Happy Ending: A Must-See Event

Update Darren Criss Makes a Triumphant Return to BroadwayOn November 5, 2025, Broadway is buzzing with excitement as Darren Criss, the multifaceted star from the hit series Glee, makes his much-anticipated return to the stage in Maybe Happy Ending. After a nine-week hiatus, Criss returns to his role as Oliver, a character that not only won him the prestigious Tony Award for Best Leading Actor in a Musical but also made him the first Asian American to receive this honor. His talent, dedication, and charisma have made him a household name, and audiences are eager to see him back at the Belasco Theatre.The Show That Captivated AudiencesMaybe Happy Ending, which debuted on November 12, 2024, is a heartwarming musical featuring a unique story set in Korea. Criss’s character, Oliver, is a retired HelperBot, reflecting on a life of waiting for connection. The musical tells a tale of hope and unexpected love between two robots, with a Tony-winning book and score crafted by Hue Park and Will Aronson. The show has already garnered acclaim, including being named one of the most nominated productions of the last Tony Awards, racking up 10 nominations and winning in key categories.Controversy Surrounding Casting ChoicesHowever, Criss's return comes on the heels of some controversy regarding casting choices during his absence. Andrew Barth Feldman, who temporarily took over Criss's role, sparked discussions within the theater community due to concerns about representation. Critics voiced disappointment over a white actor stepping into a role initially created for Asian performers. The creators addressed these concerns, emphasizing that both characters are robots whose identities transcend race, aiming to inclusively tell the story of two beings finding love and purpose. This ongoing dialogue highlights the broader conversations about diversity and representation in theater.Celebrating a Bright Future for the ProductionAs Criss resumes his role, audiences can expect the original creativity of the cast back in full force. Alongside him is Helen J Shen, who plays Claire, alongside notable talents like Dez Duron and Marcus Choi. With the production's success, plans for a North American tour set to kick off in the Fall of 2026 have already been announced, promising to bring the magic of this groundbreaking musical to cities across the continent.In a world where stories of connection resonate deeply, Maybe Happy Ending stands out as both a heartfelt and humorous exploration of companionship and love, reminding us all that happiness can sometimes come from the most unexpected places. Criss’s return marks not just a personal triumph but a significant moment in the evolution of Broadway’s diverse storytelling landscape.