Darren Criss Returns to Broadway's Maybe Happy Ending: What Fans Can Expect

Darren Criss Returns to the Spotlight in Maybe Happy Ending

On November 5, 2025, Tony winner Darren Criss made his highly anticipated return to Broadway’s Maybe Happy Ending, stepping back into his acclaimed role as Oliver, a plant-loving robot navigating friendship and love in an increasingly digital world. After a nine-week hiatus, Criss returns to the Belasco Theatre, reuniting with his original co-star, Helen J Shen, who plays Claire, another retired HelperBot.

A Milestone in Broadway History

Darren Criss made history at the 2025 Tony Awards, becoming the first Asian American to win the award for Best Leading Actor in a Musical, a feat that highlights the changing landscape of Broadway representation. This groundbreaking win has resonated deeply within the Asian American community, captivating fans who have been following his career, which catapulted to fame through Glee and continued to grow with performances in shows like How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying.

The Controversy Over Casting Choices

The transition period saw young actor Andrew Barth Feldman stepping in for Criss, a decision that was met with both support and critique from fans and theater critics alike. Some felt that casting Feldman, a White actor, in a show centered around Korean characters diminished opportunities for Asian talent in a significant production. However, the show’s creators defended their choice by noting that both characters are robots and can thus be portrayed by actors from diverse backgrounds.

What Makes Maybe Happy Ending Unique

Maybe Happy Ending isn't just a standard musical; it's a portrayal of loneliness, companionship, and the quest for meaning within the confines of a static existence. Set in a whimsical one-room apartment in Seoul, the narrative dives into the lives of two HelperBots who learn about emotions that go beyond their programming. The story, adorned with touching jazz music and vibrant performances, celebrates the complexities of friendships that can blossom under strange circumstances.

A Bright Future Ahead

Following its successful run in New York, Maybe Happy Ending is scheduled to embark on a multi-year North American tour starting in the fall of 2026, set to captivate audiences in over 30 cities, including Los Angeles, Chicago, and San Francisco. Such expansion indicates a promising and serendipitous future not just for the show, but also for the themes of diversity and exploration it represents.

The success of Maybe Happy Ending at the Tony Awards, where it garnered six wins, including Best Musical, underscores the critical acclaim it has received since its opening on November 12, 2024. This underscores the growing acceptance of new narratives in theatre, where diverse experiences are showcased on a prominent stage.

Conclusion: Celebrating Diversity in Theatre

As Darren Criss returns to the spotlight in Maybe Happy Ending, audiences have the chance to witness not just his remarkable talent, but also the evolution of storytelling on Broadway. The show's narrative resonates deeply with those exploring their own identities in today's society, making it a culturally significant piece. Whether watching in person or following the musical's journey across North America, its impact promises to be felt far into the future.