Discover Broadway's Brightest Stars at the First Annual 54 Below Gala

Is 'Anna Christie' with Michelle Williams a Timeless Revival or a Stagnant Classic?

Update Exploring 'Anna Christie': A Bold Revival or a Stagnant Ghost? Michelle Williams' portrayal of a former prostitute in Anna Christie, directed by Thomas Kail, has captured critical attention at St. Ann’s Warehouse in Brooklyn. While the production attempts to reinvigorate Eugene O’Neill’s Pulitzer Prize-winning play—initially a scandal due to its daring themes—the adaptation faces challenges that reflect a struggle between legacy and contemporary resonance. Setting the Stage: A Waterfront Production This revival situates itself closely to the waterfront, enhancing its maritime themes. However, as noted in a review from amNewYork, the play's history doesn’t make it an automatic crowd-puller. The characters' struggle with their pasts and the harsh realities of life on the docks resonate more deeply with the actors’ performances than with the dialogue, which feels overtly dated at times. During its run until February 1, there's palpable excitement from audiences to witness a classic, yet the question lingers: does it offer anything new? Tom Sturridge’s Raw Energy vs. Michelle Williams’ Fragility In this production, Sturridge's interpretation of Mat Burke has been described as raw and animalistic, adding a much-needed physicality amidst the emotional currents of the play. Critics like Jonathan Mandell from New York Theater note the disparity in how Williams and Sturridge approach their roles: Williams embodies a more subdued strength, yet some critics argue that she lacks the impactful intensity required for Anna Christopherson. The contrast between Sturridge’s ferocity and Williams’ restraint showcases the complexity of their relationship, which is crucial to the narrative’s tension. Why This Play Remains Timely Yet Timid Despite its historical context, Anna Christie provides valuable insights into gender dynamics and societal expectations that are still relevant today. Critics like Matt Windman highlight that while the production showcases star power and artistic pedigree, it struggles to justify the revival’s place in modern theater. This production may appeal to audiences unfamiliar with O’Neill's work. However, for seasoned theatergoers, the revival seems more like an homage rather than a fresh interrogation of the material. Crafting Atmosphere: Innovative Staging and Design Choices Technical elements, such as the scenography by Christine Jones and Brett J. Banakis, invite an atmosphere that works both for and against the storytelling. The physical set is designed to be flexible, yet some critics argue it distracts from character moments, leaving out crucial intuition and emotional resonance from the characters’ journeys. The use of fog, lighting by Natasha Katz, and an original score by Nicholas Britell contribute to the dramatic tone but may sometimes feel excessive, creating a separation between the audience and the actors. Reflections on a Legacy: Modern Stakes in a Classic Play The challenge, as highlighted across reviews, is how this production honors O’Neill's legacy while revisiting elements that resonate less with modern audiences. As theatergoers grapple with Anna's complex past and the male-centric views surrounding her, questions arise about the play’s relevance and whether it elicits sympathy or judgment for its characters. Ultimately, while some may find it a touching performance led by a star-studded cast, the essence of Anna Christie may not hold the depth to engage contemporary viewers as it once did.